# What to do when a customer gets the wrong item, or something's missing

When the warehouse packs the wrong thing, the real question is how much of the fix lands on the customer. Below is how I'd decide that once, with a builder at the bottom that writes the SOP for you.

*By Nathan Tone · November 16, 2026*

The email usually comes with a photo. A blue sweater where the green one should be, or a box with three of the four things they paid for. There isn't much to argue about. Someone in the warehouse reached into the wrong bin, and now you're deciding what it costs to put right and who does the work.

Brands answer that differently, and mostly it comes down to how generous they want to be. Some just send the right item. Others point the customer to the same exchange flow they'd use to swap a size. Either one is a reasonable policy. The trouble starts when nobody has picked, and one customer gets a free reship on Tuesday while another gets a return label on Thursday for the same mistake.

## Decide how generous you want to be

Reshipping is the generous end. The correct item goes out today and the customer doesn't lift a finger. It costs you a second item, and the first one too if you let them keep it. For a customer who just opened the wrong box, it's about the best way that moment can go.

The exchange flow is the careful end. You already run it for size swaps, the wrong item comes back to stock, and nothing ships twice. The catch is that you're asking the customer to do the work of fixing your mistake: start the exchange, pack the box, drop it off, wait.

Plenty of brands land in between and split by order value. Under a number you pick, reship. Over it, the exchange flow, with the return label on you. If you've read the [never-got-their-order playbook](https://www.wrrk.com/playbooks/customer-says-they-never-got-their-order/), it's the same idea: count how many of these you get in a month, look at what a reship actually costs, and set the number where that total sits comfortably.

## Check the order before anything else

Before treating it as a packing mistake, take a minute to make sure it is one.

- **Compare what arrived with the order's line items.** If they received exactly the variant they ordered, it's a regular exchange under your normal policy. Be kind about it: people tap the wrong size all the time.
- **For a missing item, look at the order's fulfillments.** If it's in a separate shipment that's still on the way, or it's backordered, tell them where it is and when to expect it. Glance at the packing slip too, in case a small piece was packed inside something bigger.

Anything else is a mistake, and it goes down whichever path you picked.

## When you reship

Check the correct item is in stock and send it. Under your number I wouldn't ask for a photo; it slows things down for a customer who's almost certainly right. Over it, a photo of what arrived and the packing slip is a fair ask, and it gives the warehouse something to look at.

Then decide what happens to the wrong item. On a cheap item, let them keep it. Getting it back costs more than it's worth, and the customer has to make a trip to do it. On a pricier one, send a prepaid return label, and don't hold the reship until the return arrives.

> "I'm sorry we sent the wrong item. The correct one is on its way, and I'll send tracking as soon as it ships. Please keep the one you received, no need to send it back."

## When you use the exchange flow

Make it as light as you can. Send the exchange link in your first reply, cover the return shipping, and say plainly that it's on you because the mistake was yours. Tell them when the correct item will ship so they aren't left wondering.

A missing item has nothing to send back, so the exchange flow doesn't fit. Reship those, whatever the order value.

> "I'm sorry we sent the wrong item. You can swap it for the right one on our exchange page, and return shipping is on us since the mistake was ours. Your correct item ships as soon as the exchange goes through."

## When it's someone else's whole order

Now and then a customer opens the box and nothing in it is theirs. It doesn't happen often, and when it does, reship their order with no questions, whatever it's worth. Then look at orders packed around the same time. Somebody else probably has this customer's things, and they'll be writing in soon.

## When the correct item is out of stock

Say what happened and let them choose: a similar item, waiting for the restock with a date if you have one, or a refund for the item. Decide ahead of time which of those you're willing to offer, so the answer doesn't depend on who picks up the ticket.

## Tell the warehouse every time

Each confirmed mis-pick should go back to whoever packs your orders with the order number, the SKU that should have shipped, the SKU that did, and the photo if you have one. Tag the ticket as well, so you can count them.

One report on its own is easy to shrug off. A month of them usually shows a pattern: two SKUs that sit next to each other on a shelf, or two sizes that look the same in the bag. That's something the warehouse can actually fix, and it means fewer of these tickets next month.

## When it keeps happening to the same customer

Tags make repeat claims easy to spot. After a couple in a year, have someone on your team look before anything else ships, or offer the regular exchange instead of a free reship. Either way, stay kind. A customer who keeps getting the wrong item may just have unlucky timing with a warehouse that has a problem.

## Isn't reshipping every time expensive?

It costs something, but the mistake already happened, and the customer didn't make it. Every option has a cost. With the exchange flow you pay in return shipping and a slower, more annoyed customer. With a reship you pay in a second item.

The bigger lever is the warehouse report. Fewer mis-picks means fewer of these tickets at all, and that's what makes a generous policy affordable.

## Writing it down

The point of all this is to make the call once, before the email arrives. In our work, we put these rules in the SOP and have AI reason over the SOP, the order, and the customer's message to put together the action and the reply, so the same mistake gets the same fix every time.

You can get most of the way there without any AI by writing the rules down. Pick where you sit in the builder below and it'll write a first version of the SOP, reply templates included, that you can hand to your team.

---

Original post, with the interactive SOP builder and AI agent prompt: https://www.wrrk.com/playbooks/wrong-or-missing-item/
